Question Everything, A 4th of July Meditation


As it’s the 4th of July, I just posted an American flag by Andy Warhol on Facebook along with Whitney Houston’s video singing the Star Spangled Banner. I surfed through my friends’ remarks for the day, lots of flags and remembrances of those who fought for our freedom and support for our courageous troops who are still serving, as well as those who’ve paid the ultimate price.

It’s heart-moving and provocative emotionally to see the out-pouring of patriotism. But ever since I was a kid and learned about the divisions of borders, other countries, some hostile, some brutal to their people and what has been done in the name of patriotism (not to mention religion), I’ve had serious doubts about the separations these kind of loyalties create. And last night I was with a playful and talented group of people at a karaoke party where people sang plenty of good ‘ole American songs, and wore red, white and blue blouses and hats. Holidays are always great reasons to get together with others and celebrate. One guy sang Toby Keith’s notorious hit “Courtesy for the Red, White and Blue” almost as good as Toby himself.

I listen to country, corny as the lyrics can be, I like the stories, I like the beat. But I can get pretty uncomfortable with the raging nationalism. I remember the first time I heard the song, also called “The Angry American.” I was living in Boston and it was in the wake of 9/11, a time of heightened patriotism when America had the sympathy of most of the world. There were some lines in the song that offended some of us peacenicks, such as, “The Statue of Liberty is shaking her fist . . . Man, it’s gonna be hell when you hear Mother Freedom start ringin’ her bell and it feels like whole wide world is raining down on you . . . ” then, “we”ll put a boot in your ass, It’s the American way . . . “

In my opinion, it is outrageous, but on another level, I could see his viewpoint and chuckle at the machoism. I grew up in NY, I’ve got that dark humor, and it’s not outrageous in terms of the particular individual that Toby is. Many of his songs reflect attitudes that I don’t embrace but I find him a terrific singer and songwriter and could certainly see where he was coming from. 9/11 was horrific and his millions of fans here and overseas love the song. I’m a die-hard liberal but I admire the clever lyrics and the passionate music.

It’s a revenge song for sure and it talks about “lighting up” the enemy’s “sky like the 4th of July,” which we can directly associate not only to the war in Afghanistan, but especially the “Shock and Awe” which came later as the U.S. military began bombing Iraq. On faulty information as it turned out. And a lot of innocent people were killed. That’s not a chuckling matter.I don’t support the euphemism of “collateral damage.”

When I heard the song last night on the eve of the July 4th, I thought of another artist, Alice Walker, feminist Afro-American poet, novelist and activist. Years ago, teaching one of her essays to college freshmen, I came across her poem, “On Sight” which is embedded in the essay. In it she references the moon-landing of 1969, when astronauts planted the American flag on the moon. Here are some of her lines, the latter part of the poem:

The desert has its own moon
Which I have seen
With my own eye.

There is no flag on it.

Trees of the desert have arms
All of which are always up
That is because the moon is up
The sun is up
Also the sky
The Stars
Clouds
None with flags.

Point being, can you really own the moon? Do we even own the land? Native Americans thought they belonged to the land, not the other way round. Patriotism is nice to celebrate, a country’s birthday is a good excuse for a holiday, and we like holidays, watermelon, hot dogs and apple pie . . but . . . this late in history, at a time when technology has brought the entire world into communication and more and more young people around the world are creating the same culture, at a time when the entire planet’s environment is threatened by consumerism, overpopulation and continuing wars, too much patriotism may be an outdated, and dangerous habit.

Basic world values are also becoming more similar, countries are still struggling for democracy, even as our citizens raise questions about what true democracy is. Does the congress really represent our country and its changing population? Does it consider what is in the best interests of its constituents, or has it sold out to corporations and lobbyists? Is our media even reflective of true democracy? Or is it designed to keep us in a trance? It appears up front and personal until you really examine the profit over loss principle of capitalism behind it. Who are those guys on Wall Street that caused the melt-down anyway? And what kind of democracy lets them off scott-free?

Maybe we should have World Day, celebrate the Big Bang, the whole creation of oceans and continents unto every corner of the earth. Celebrate people everywhere who are willing to envision real global change. People who are protesting what they don’t like about the world. I like our flag, but back in the sixties I agreed with those who burned it in protest to the country’s activities in Viet Nam. It’s just a symbol after all. And a symbol is only as good as what it represents. Some people forget we have a right to protest our government. A symbol is also an easy way to rally sentimentality (which is feeling without substance behind it). Dividing people according to religion or borders is always a good way to control private interests and sometimes that’s what nationalism does.

Even as a kid I was always freaked out by the Star Spangled Banner’s bombs bursting line. And those bombs are kind of like fireworks. I prefer John Lennon’s lines in Imagine, “Imagine there’s no countries/ It isn’t hard to do/Nothing to kill or die for/And no religion too.”

And I know I’m not the only dreamer. . . Socrates called himself a citizen of the world, not just Athens. Then again, they gave him the choice of hemlock or exile. He took the hemlock because, as he said his “daimon” or intuition did not object when he thought that being exiled would defeat the purpose of his life which was to teach the youth of Athens to question everything.

9 Comments

  • By cindy, July 5, 2012 @ 3:06 pm

    WOW…. Deb, so well written and heart felt. And how true. You are a true artist. I love your thoughts, your knowledge and your words. Very provocative ….

  • By Dr. Erica Goodstone, July 9, 2012 @ 1:08 pm

    Deborah,

    I do understand your perspective. Having been on a spiritual path and meditating often for many years, I cannot think of “my country” as opposed to the world.
    One of my Pinterest boards, Wonders of the World, is filled with images of the most incredible and amazing scenery in every part of the world. No one country is better than any other.

    And a few of my images are these beautiful places in Vietnam. When I was young, Vietnam was a terrifying, dangerous place with bombs planted everywhere. Who could have imagined it would later become this beautiful, peaceful tourist attraction.

    I would like to see us come together as one world. But the problem starts in small groups. As chair of a department at my college (when I was a professor), there was so much dissension among faculty members who worked together for years. If we can’t overcome even small differences in small groups, how can we achieve planetary solidarity?

    Warmly,

    Dr. Erica

  • By Deborah, July 9, 2012 @ 3:50 pm

    i agree with you Erica. People like to identify with a group and that’s good. We just have to keep expanding the groups to be more inclusive. I know I am talking idealistically, and it seems so many groups form because they are against another group! I think that it’s important for people to get out of their groups and experience others who are different from them. We get that experience when we travel abroad, for instance. If everyone would expand their personal borders we might see a more interesting mindset. I do believe we are moving toward the understanding of oneness as we begin to see how interdependent the nations are that make up our planet.

  • By Joan Brooks, July 9, 2012 @ 11:36 pm

    Deborah, at the heart of what you are saying is the difference between patriarchy and feminine power. Patriarchy demands hierarchy and one-up-mans-ship. Patriarchy demands that there be a “you” and an “other”, who is either less than you and to be dominated and controlled, or better than you, then to be idolized. In patriarchy, there is a great need to divide and conquer, so those in power can remain in power. Nationalism is just one way that gets played out. And yes, it is destructive.

    We need more feminism and feminine ways – ones of collaboration and inclusion. Only then we will be able to shift from US to “us”.

    Thank you for so courageously speaking about this.

    Joan

  • By Deborah, July 9, 2012 @ 11:54 pm

    An important distinction, Joan. That’s another way to state the difference in mindset, or should I say heartset? 2012 is the year of beginning this transition. & Thank you for your insight.

  • By Rick Lelchuk, July 17, 2012 @ 9:59 am

    Deborah,

    I started to comment on your post a dozen times and discarded each one for a variety of reasons.

    You are right, raging Nationalism can be detrimental, but not patriotism. How do we combat the raging Nationalism of other countries? What does America do about fanatics who want to see her destruction? Who would come to defend a way of life we’ve all come to enjoy and cherish? The Patriots.

    There is certainly a growing global community because of technology, but, I’d venture to say that people remain the same in spite of it being late in history and the electronic connection. Some will evolve, most will not.

    Joan commented about the difference between patriarchal and matriarchal thinking and you acknowledged her point. The differences between men and women are undeniable and probably unsolvable. Isn’t that ironic? Men and women will always see things differently. It’s natural, Mother Nature’s personal chuckle. So too, I believe, will the unification of nations.

    Thanks for provoking thought!

    RICK

  • By Sheree Diamond, The Flow Doctor, September 12, 2012 @ 3:33 pm

    I believe that we are all one therefore all countries and all people are equal. I don’t believe in wars or that our country is better than another. I like what you said about having a “World Day.”

  • By Deborah, July 5, 2016 @ 1:27 pm

    Thank you Sheree, I am just seeing this comment now! I haven’t been too active on this lately
    due to another job.

  • By Deborah, September 12, 2012 @ 4:53 pm

    Thank you Sheree. I write this on 9/12 after the Ambassador to Libya and 3 others were killed by Islamic extremists this morning in reaction to a hate-Muslim film aired by fundamentalist extremists in our own country. It saddens me terribly how intolerant of others’ beliefs people can be.

Other Links to this Post

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

WordPress Themes